I only went out to see one film last month and I'm not going to bury the lede - I liked BATMAN V SUPERMAN:
DAWN OF JUSTICE. I realize that puts me in the unenviable position of liking
something that the broader popular consensus has decided is garbage, but I'm
comfortable with that. I often like movies that others despise and I've never
cared before so why start now. I am a little surprised by the magnitude of the
outright hatred generated by this film though. Well - I'm surprised by the
non-geek hatred. I'm never surprised by geek hatred. Nerd Rage is a daily fact
of life in the 21st century and if you have any interest in listening you can
find some group, someplace, bitching about any and all details small and large
about every geeky topic you can image - and some you would be shocked to learn
about. These days, of course, superhero movies are at the top of the list of
bitched about geeky things. Everyone has something to complain about and, in
some cases, I can agree that a case is being made that is worthy of attention.
I've certainly had problems with some recent superhero films, but overall I'm
very happy and outside of hideous missteps like GREEN LANTERN I've enjoyed much
more about the genre than I've disliked. I think that might be because I've
always had a fondness for new and different interpretations of these classic
characters. I don't feel that something I love is being destroyed just because
it isn't exactly the way I pictured it. I actually WANT to see different
versions of these characters and I don't mind the darker tone at all.
In fact, I love seeing these decades old characters taken
down less sunny paths because it allows for some dramatic tension. I have a
fondness for the Christopher Reeve
Superman films but I never doubted for a second that he would prevail in
the end. With this story I can't be sure of anything. Here Batman has been at
his thing for twenty years with Alfred a weary veteran of his ongoing battle
against crime in Gotham . That's cool! Superman
is new to this hero thing and is very unsure of the correct path for his future
and worries that the public sees him as more a threat than a benefit. Seeing
the fear that his power causes in some people fills him with uncertainty about
his place in his adopted world. That's fantastic! He's not a do-gooder 'god' -
he's a man with real concerns about unintended consequences and blowback. Excellent!
This is already more interesting than it needs to be in my opinion and we
haven't even gotten to the plot! Or the great introduction of Wonder Woman. Why
did it take this damned long to get her on the big screen?
The List
KING
SOLOMON'S MINES (1950)- 7 (good adventure tale)
PRAY
FOR DEATH (1985)- 4 (pretty bad ninja movie)
THE
NEW BARBARIANS (1983)- 6 (rewatch)
CYBORG
2: GLASS SHADOW (1993)- 3 (terrible)
FINAL
EXAM (1981) - 4 (not good but watchable)
THE
MAN WITH THE GOLDEN GUN (1974) - 6 (rewatch)
THE
BELLBOY (1960)- 5 (Jerry Lewis)
CORMAN'S
WORLD:EXPLOITS OF A HOLLYWOOD REBEL (2011) - 8 (excellent documentary on Roger
Corman)
HUNTERS
OF THE GOLDEN COBRA (1982)- 5
THE
KEY (1934)- 6 (love triangle set in Ireland in 1920 with William
Powell, Colin Clive)
DRACULA
(1958) - 9 (Hammer's classic on Blu!) (rewatch)
THE
MASK (1961) - 6 (rewatch)
BATMAN
V SUPERMAN: DAWN OF JUSTICE (2016) - 8
EASY
COME, EASY GO (1967)- 5 (amiable, silly and colorful Elvis film)
2 comments:
Dark superhero movies can be good. Flashpoint is a prime example, although I don't know how most people accept that movie. With Man of Steel most people either loved or hated it. I myself haven't seen BvS, but the criticism seems based on the filmmaking, instead of the presentation of the characters. The destruction of Metropolis and Superman killing Zod were the biggest complaints of the previous film. This one is garnering such complaints as the dream sequences, the performance of Lex Luther, and a plethora of others. I didn't think Man of Steel was as bad as what everyone made it to be. I liked it more than Superman Returns, but not as much as Superman 1-3. However, unlike most of the haters, I will eventually watch BvS and judge it on it's own merits.
And judging it on its own merits is what should happen. To your point - I loved MAN OF STEEL so it shouldn't be a surprise I liked this follow up. I have problems with all of the various live action Superman films - ALL of them - but most of the hatred for this and MOS seemed more like ginned up rage than real critiques. The 'Superman shouldn't be dark' folks need to chill the fuck out. Having human foibles makes the character better not worse.
Post a Comment