Mash-Ups of different franchises are often a bad idea. In
most cases they end up not pleasing fans of the two separate properties and the
end product comes out as something that is considered a failure by everyone
involved. Horror fans need look no further than FREDDY VS JASON or ALIEN VS
PREDATOR to see a couple of crowd dis-pleasing cinema mash-ups that were far
less than the sum of their parts.
Of course, what doesn't necessarily work onscreen can
sometimes be made to work on the page such as the excellent Alien vs. Predator
Dark Horse comics from the 1990's that could have been the template for a
better (if not great) film. Also, there have been some fascinating Friday the
13th comic book series that have incorporated elements from outside the film
series to good effect including crossovers with Ash from the EVIL DEAD films.
And there are a host of non-graphic novels out there that extend and add to
various cinema series in creative and entertaining ways that please the
hardcore fans who are the obvious target audience for these 'extended universe'
stories. Hell- I'm still trying to collect the entire run of Friday the 13th
novels written as sequels to my beloved JASON X!
So, it appears to me that the best way - for now - to
continue to create successful mash-ups is to do it on the page and for a case
to make this point I give you IDW and Boom Studios new comic book series Star
Trek/Planet of the Apes. At first glance I was harrumphing at the very idea of
slapping these two very different types of science fiction together. They
clearly exist in extremely different universes both in subject matter and
style. There seemed no way to place the original Star Trek crew in contact with
the Planet of the Apes post apocalyptic world that could possible make sense.
The very basis of classic Trek is an optimistic view of the future where many
of the problems we think of as insurmountable have been solved. But the basic
premise of POTA is that mankind was so short sighted that they couldn't keep
from destroying the world. How to put these two franchises together in a way
that did not compromise either one?
2 comments:
I'm shocked by this! About two weeks ago I was joking around with my wife because I bought POTA figures. I threw out this crossover and a Death Wish version of Planet of the Apes. Are there any crossovers you've thought of over the years?
I've thought of dozens of Mash-Ups over the years- all of which would have sucked!!:-)
I once wished for a Six Million Dollar Man crossover with Buck Rogers. Stupid! Of course, I was 10, so what did I know? I also want Steve Austin to fight the Hulk but that one could have worked in the TV world of the 1970's.
Post a Comment